| Platinum | Milwaukee Burger Co. Bar and Grill |
| Gold | Chick-a-Dee's Family Restaurant |
| Silver | Ramones Ice Cream Parlor |
| Bronze | Hangar 54 Grill |
| Top Pick | C and T Soul Food |
| Top Pick | Genos Pizza |
| Top Pick | Houligan's Steak & Seafood Pub |
| Top Pick | Johnny's Italian Steakhouse |
| Top Pick | Livery Restaurant & Cowtown Saloon |
| Top Pick | Ray's Place |