| Platinum | Fosters Fireside |
| Gold | Pizza Del Re |
| Silver | Sammy's Pizza |
| Bronze | Jimbob's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Johnny's Pizza Shop |
| Top Pick | Next Door Pizza Pub |
| Top Pick | Papa Johns Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rocky Rococo Pizza & Pasta |
| Top Pick | Tony Capony (formerly godfathers pizza) |
| Top Pick | Topper's Pizza |