| Platinum | Casa Vallarta |
| Gold | Silly Serrano Mexican Restaurant |
| Silver | Tacos Juanita |
| Bronze | Casa Margarita |
| Top Pick | California Tacos |
| Top Pick | Cancun Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Casa Mexicana |
| Top Pick | Guac N Roll |
| Top Pick | NE NE's Tacos |
| Top Pick | Rancho Grande Bar & Grill |